About Allagash
Founding and Ownership Structure
Allagash’s investment management business was initially conceived and designed by Founding CEO / Co-CIO Tony Barkan to provide investors with institutional quality access to the wealth of opportunities generated by the seemingly intractable and currently expanding shortage in rental housing affordable to LMI households throughout the U.S. As per the National Housing Trust: “For every affordable apartment created, two are lost to deterioration, abandonment…”1 leading to a situation in which 49% of households earning 50% to 80% of AMI (approximately 6 million households), and 24% of households making 80% to 100% of AMI (an additional approximately 2 million households), are rent cost-burdened, paying greater than 30% of their gross income for rent.2
Allagash PERE Investment Management, LLC (“APIM”), the Investment Manager for Allagash’s private equity real estate (“PERE”) offerings, is based in Richmond with offices in New York City and Denver. APIM is owned and controlled by its team of five founding co-managing principals listed below (the “Partners”), each of whom has over 20 years of experience in real estate and financial markets. Cumulatively, the Partners have over 150 years of institutional real estate and financial market experience over half of which is directly applicable to institutional investment fund management, LMI real estate investing, and SFR+ investing and managing.
- [Ellen Lurie Hoffman, National Housing Trust, Preserving America’s Affordable Rental Housing: The CRE Case, 5/21/2018.]
- [2022 American Community Survey – Public Use Microdata as published in The Gap Report by National Housing Coalition 3/2024.]
Founding Partnership Team

Tony Barkan
CEO / CO-CIO

Simon Russell
COO / CO-CIO

David Puchi
Business Development

To Be Announced*
Construction Management

Mara Zingg
Property Management
Advisory Board Members
Ron Freydberg
Ron Freydberg
Ron Freydberg currently is a Westchester, NY-based investor and business advisor for multiple SFR-oriented businesses including Allagash SFR Holdings, LLC, the owner and controlling party of Allagash SFR Investment Management, LLC and ASFRIP GP, LLC, and Vantage Homes, the Property Manager for the Partnership. From 2021-2022, Mr. Freydberg worked for Anarock Capital as Chief Operating Officer and Chief Compliance Officer.
For over 20 years from 1997 to 2020, Mr. Freydberg worked at MFA Financial, Inc., a publicly traded REIT. He served in a variety of roles including Founder, Chief Investment Office, and Chief Administrative Officer. While overseeing a team of over 20 people at MFA who worked to ensure efficiency in day-to-day administrative and operational functions, Mr. Freydberg’s responsibilities included negotiating the company’s financing transactions, Chairing the Technology Steering Committee, and acting as the primary contact for the firm’s various transactional and service counterparties.
Prior to joining MFA, Mr. Freydberg worked at Pentalpha Capital, performing fixed income and asset-back advisory services for portfolio managers, money managers, and hedge fund advisors. He began his career at JP Morgan and Citigroup.
Mr. Freydberg holds a BA in Business Administration from Muhlenberg College and an MBA in Finance from George Washington University.
Michael A. Commaroto
Michael A. Commaroto
Michael A. Commaroto, since 2016, has been the Managing Member of Bruce Park Management, LLC (“BPM”), a family office established to invest opportunistically in mortgage assets and real estate development. BPM has funded investments in sub and non-performing residential mortgage loans and short duration “fix and flip” loans as well as the development of select Dollar General stores in the New England area.
Additionally, Mr. Commaroto serves as a senior advisor to and co-investor with a boutique special servicer with investments in distressed first and second mortgage liens, as well as business interests in both the US and the Caribbean Basin. Prior to founding BPM, Mr. Commaroto was a Partner in Apollo Global Management (“Apollo”) from 2014 through 2016 and served as the Chief Executive Officer and President of Apollo Residential Mortgage Inc and its investment manager, ARM Manager from 2011 to 2016. Prior to that from 2008 to 2014, Mr. Commaroto was the Chief Executive Officer – Capital Markets of Vantium Management, L.P., (“Vantium”) an Apollo-sponsored investment manager with a focus on investing in residential mortgage loans and mortgage-backed securities.
Prior to joining Vantium, Mr. Commaroto was at Deutsche Bank AG (NYSE: DB), as the US Head of Whole Loan Trading. Mr. Commaroto joined Deutsche Bank in 2000 and under his leadership through 2007, the trading desk was responsible for the issuance of over $50 billion of asset-backed and mortgage-backed securities collateralized by mortgage loans that it had purchased.
Prior to joining Deutsche Bank, Mr. Commaroto spent over 16 years at Credit Suisse First Boston and its predecessor companies, where, among other responsibilities, he managed the whole loan trading and finance business for the Principal Trading Group and the Mortgage Department. Mr. Commaroto started his career at Arthur Andersen & Co. where he focused on auditing broker dealers and investment banks.
Mr. Commaroto graduated from Union College with a BA in economics and from the University of Rochester with an MBA with a concentration in accounting and finance.
* Names and Bios available subject to NDA.
Founding Principles, Objectives, and Investment Precepts
The Allagash team of Principals; Tony Barkan, Simon Russell, David Puchi, Mara Zingg, and the Head of Construction Management (planned joining: 2Q2025); are drawing upon their extensive experience to formulate their Founding Principles, the Firm’s Objectives, and the Investment Precepts for their offerings.
3 Founding Principles:
- Investments in SFR+ Properties affordably serving LMI communities should enable investors to generate outsized returns without being exposed to excessive risk;
- Providing affordable housing to LMI households should be positively socially impactful;
- The combination of the first two principles is accretive to both.
3 Firm Objectives:
- Preserve investor capital by considering risk throughout the Partnership’s lifecycle;
- Create observable and long-lasting positive social impact through the investment process;
- Maximize investor returns without compromising either of the other objectives.
3 Investment Precepts:
- By demonstrating directly within the operating documents of each investment vehicle the intent to create positive social impact and by fostering an ongoing dialogue with a wide range of community members, investment management can promote community support for investments and thereby increase return potential and reduce risk;
- The most efficient method to generate solid real estate returns is to source opportunistically, add value thoughtfully, and manage diligently and efficiently;
- Exit strategies should consider pricing, tax implications, and the outcome for impacted LMI communities in order to maximize both total returns for investors and long term positive social impact for communities.
The SFR+ Strategy & Process
The seeds of Allagash’s SFR+ strategy were sown during CEO Tony Barkan’s tenure at Seer Capital Management, which coincided with the establishment of the institutional SFR industry. Mr. Barkan initially determined that the largest SFR investment management franchises were basically executing a levered real estate strategy rather than creating efficient operating companies which could generate significant stable income. In contrast, Mr. Barkan worked from the beginning to establish Seer as a profitable and socially-responsible renter of housing to LMI households. In designing this model, Mr. Barkan crafted an investment process that he believes offers the highest probability of achieving both outsized IRRs with meaningful distributions for investors and positive social impact.
Allagash’s SFR+ offering is designed to expand and improve upon the SFR model Mr. Barkan employed at Seer. Instead of focusing entirely on single-family residences, Allagash SFR+ Impact Partners LP will also seek to purchase properties with buildings of 2-16 units, a cohort of housing that Allagash has termed as SFR+. Allagash has chosen to focus the Partnership’s investment activities on purchasing and managing SFR+ Properties serving LMI households in secondary MSAs based upon extensive research (i) generally on the pricing dynamics within the market for residential rental housing throughout the United States and (ii) specifically on the seemingly intractable and expanding supply shortage in affordable rental housing for members of working-class communities throughout the United States. With respect to residential real estate markets generally, Allagash finds that the pricing and availability of LMI-affordable residential rental
properties, especially those comprised of smaller scale buildings with 1 to 16 units in which the majority of units have 2 or more bedrooms, is extremely attractive on both a relative and outright basis. With seemingly little competitive demand for these properties, they can be purchased with a cost basis that allows affordable LMI rents to be charged while still providing compelling projected return profiles for investors into such properties. Allagash believes these returns are significantly more attractive than those available from properties serving renters higher up the economic spectrum or from larger scale properties generally.
While the four steps of Allagash’s PERE investment process (Opportunistical Sourcing, Thoughtfully Add- Value, Efficient Management, and Strategic Sale) seem deceptively simple, each step involves rigorous planning, active decision-making, and continuous risk evaluation. Allagash believes that this process’ success relies upon having the right structure and the right team in place, which Allagash believes it has accomplished.
Social Impact – Investor IRR Synergy
Because the Partnership’s capacity to generate compelling, stable returns and positive social impact arises from a single root cause: the scarcity of capital invested into LMI SFR+ housing. Allagash sees that these objectives are also complementary.
The Partnership invests capital and provides quality housing to LMI households to combat the affordable housing crisis; in turn, excess demand for the Partnership’s affordable housing product can provide outsized returns to investors.
Community Development Entity
Allagash is in the process of becoming certified by the U.S. Department of the Treasury as a Community Development Entity (“CDE”) which will allow the LMI communities into which Allagash-managed funds invest to understand that Allagash plans to work with the members of their community to provide the best outcome for both the community members as well as the investments in any Allagash QOF.
Corporate Responsibility
Allagash is a signatory to the UN-backed Principles for Responsible Investing (PRI). We have in place a formal governance structure which aligns our investment processes and achievements with the overarching goals of the responsible investment movement. Our Management Committee governs and supports our responsible investing activities with the aid of our Advisory Committee which reviews the implementation of our Responsible Investment Policy Statement and its coordination with other relevant policies including the Allagash Code of Ethics.